Alec Baldwin manslaughter trial revolves round Wild West gun

Jul 9, 2024 | blog

By Andrew Hay

SANTA FE, New Mexico (Reuters) – The interior workings of a Colt .45 “Peacemaker” revolver, a logo of the American Wild West, have develop into the main focus of Alec Baldwin’s trial for the 2021 deadly capturing of “Rust” cinematographer Halyna Hutchins on a New Mexico film set.

Jury choice was set to start on Tuesday practically three years after Baldwin was directed to level his gun at Hutchins as she arrange a digital camera shot inside a movie-set church about 20 miles southwest of Santa Fe.

Hutchin’s 2021 loss of life was Hollywood’s first on-set capturing fatality in three a long time and momentarily sparked calls to finish the widespread use of actual firearms on film units.

Baldwin’s involuntary manslaughter trial in a contemporary, brown-stucco courthouse in downtown Santa Fe is predicted to final eight days and run to July 19.

It is exceptional in that there’s little or no precedent in U.S. historical past for an actor to face legal prosecution for an on-set capturing loss of life. The “30 Rock” actor may very well be imprisoned for as much as 18 months if discovered responsible.

In March, “Rust” armorer Hannah Gutierrez, the set worker in command of firearm security, was discovered responsible of involuntary manslaughter by a Santa Fe, New Mexico, jury for mistakenly loading a reside spherical into Baldwin’s gun. Gutierrez acquired the utmost 18-month sentence.

Legal analysts and firearms specialists had lengthy anticipated Baldwin’s case to hinge on whether or not he ought to have inspected the gun after he was informed it was “cold,” an trade time period that means it was empty or contained inert, dummy rounds.

But in a pivotal interview in December 2021, Baldwin informed ABC News’ George Stephanopoulos he didn’t pull the set off, sending prosecutors and protection legal professionals into the world of forensic firearms testing.

Baldwin, 66, stated he cocked the replica 1873 Single Action Army pistol earlier than it fired a reside spherical that killed the rising-star cinematographer and wounded director Joel Souza.

Santa Fe police got down to check Baldwin’s claims. An FBI examination discovered the gun was labored usually and wouldn’t hearth at full cock with out the set off pulled. State prosecutors filed prices thereafter, alleging Baldwin was mendacity concerning the set off.

Baldwin’s authorized staff final yr countered with photographic proof the Italian-made Pietta gun’s full-cock notch had been filed down, making it simpler to fireplace. That allowed a mechanical failure or “accidental discharge” with no set off pull, they stated.


Whether the revolver was modified or not, authorized consultants see an uphill battle for the prosecution to show Baldwin knew he may kill Hutchins however confirmed willful disregard to the chance – a degree of legal negligence required for an involuntary manslaughter conviction.

“The gun is probably the best defense, because there is no way to definitively say what the condition of the firearm was,” stated gun historian Ashley Hlebinsky who’s govt director of the University of Wyoming Firearms Research Center.

Prosecutors final yr dropped prices, satisfied the gun was modified, solely to have a grand jury reinstate them in January after unbiased firearms professional Lucien Haag confirmed findings of the FBI examination.

The FBI destroyed the gun throughout testing and the actor’s legal professionals stated they had been left with no approach to show it was modified.

“The worst proof towards Baldwin is the FBI ballistics report that claims he pulled the set off, and his ABC interview the place he stated he didn’t,” said Neama Rahmani, a Los Angeles trial attorney and former federal prosecutor.

Another possible hurdle for the prosecution is persuading jurors Baldwin is guilty of criminal negligence after Gutierrez and first assistant director Dave Halls were convicted for the shooting. Halls accepted blame in a plea deal, acknowledging he did not check rounds in Baldwin’s gun. He was convicted on a misdemeanor charge and given a six-month suspended sentence.

“Juries have issue with the concept that individuals can share guilt,” said University of New Mexico law professor Joshua Kastenburg, a former lawyer and judge in the U.S. Air Force.

Still, jurors may not buy Baldwin’s argument that, as an actor, he was not responsible for firearms safety and relied on set experts like Gutierrez and Halls.

Gun ownership is common in the Southwest United States where there is a cultural norm to check a weapon and never point it at someone and pull the trigger, according to Hlebinsky.

Then there is Baldwin’s on-set behavior.

Using videos and photos from “Rust” filming, state prosecutor Morrissey will try to show Baldwin was a man with “no management of his feelings,” whose “off script” firing of weapons and pointing them at crew contributed to a collapse in firearms security, in line with court docket filings.

The two different strongest individuals on the set, Souza and Halls, are prone to defend the actor. Both have been known as as witnesses by the protection and prosecution, respectively.

During Gutierrez’s trial, Souza and Halls dismissed Baldwin’s on-set antics as typical of high-powered actors.

© Reuters. FILE PHOTO: An undated photo of the reproduction 1873 long Colt .45 Single Action Army revolver actor Alec Baldwin was using on the New Mexico set of western movie

Baldwin’s finest protection could also be doubts his legal professionals can sow concerning the workings of the pistol, in line with Hlebinsky.

“I don’t think anyone can say 100% what happened,” stated the firearms historian, who has acted as an professional in court docket instances on single motion Colt. 45 kind revolvers just like Baldwin’s.

MoneyMaker FX EA Trading Robot

powered by